Unveiling
Gatsby and Daisy’s mysteries
Gatsby tells
Nick his history: born rich, went to Oxford, gleaming career in military at
war; he even shows off pieces of token proving his story. At lunch with Gatsby,
Nick met the Jewish world gambler, Mr. Wolfshiem. On the other hand, Jordan
also tells Nick Daisy’s history: how she fell in love with a young officer
named Jay Gatsby, the separation, her marriage with Tom Buchanan, and how she reacted
on her wedding day after receiving a letter that made her cried aloud. Then she
had a baby, while Tom started cheating on her. It turns out that Gatsby had
planned everything—bought the mansion, hosted parties—only to get closer to
Daisy again, and now he needs Nick’s help for his plan.
The
anticipated meeting
Gatsby puts
big effort in asking Nick to invite Daisy to his house for tea, so that Gatsby
can meet her there. He is so excited at the moment which he’d anticipated so
much for five years; that the happiness of actually meeting Daisy at last doesn’t
appear as he’d expected. Gatsby shows off the luxury of his mansion to Daisy;
but his wealth suddenly looses its value in front of Daisy, and even the green
light across the bay looses its sacredness once Daisy becomes reachable.
When
hope is more real than reality
Why does
Gatsby look confuse and restless when he finally meets Daisy? Out of shyness?
Or is it because he is too excited? No, I believe it’s because he finds that
the meeting he had imagined and planned for so long did not happen to be as he’d
expected. This happens to us often, an event we’ve been anticipating for so
long, that we’ve been working so hard to make it perfect, turns out to be just
like that—not as special as we’ve expected. It’s because imagination is always
better than realization. But does it mean that we ought not to have dreams? No,
I believe we need to have dreams, as it gives us purpose to fight and work hard,
it will guide us to achieve something. Although Gatsby seems to be a fool to
have done absurd things to win Daisy, I think it’s not all his fault; he’d done
that in the name of love, and love does make us foolish sometime.
Favorite
passages
“He hadn’t once ceased looking at Daisy, and
I think he revalued everything in his home according to the measure of response
it drew from her well-loved eyes. (…) He stared around at his possessions in a
dazed way, as though in her actual and astounding presence none of it was any
longer real.” ~p 97.
“A faint doubt had occurred to him as to the
quality of his present happiness. There must have been moments even that
afternoon when Daisy tumbled short of his dreams—not through her own fault, but
because of the colossal vitality of his illusion. It had gone beyond her,
beyond everything. He had thrown himself into it with a creative passion,
adding to it all the time, decking it out with every bright feather that
drifted his way. No amount of fire or freshness can challenge what a man can
store up in his ghostly heart.” ~p. 102.
They are
perhaps just any ordinary passages for you, but I loved it so much, especially the
second one. It seems to be distinguished from the others (particularly in
chapter 4 and 5). I think it has made me officially in love with Fitzgerald’s
writing!
Confusing
passage
It’s from what
Jordan Baker says to Nick about why Gatsby must ask Jordan to ask Nick
whether he’d mind to do him a favor: “He’s
afraid. He’s waited so long, he thought you might be offended. You see, he’s regular tough underneath it all.”
~p. 83
I don’t
understand what Jordan means by ‘he’s regular tough underneath it all.’ Does
she means Gatsby is thoroughly a violent person (tough = violent)? I
think Gatsby is only too afraid of making the smallest mistake that would break his
delicate bubble of hope. Or else he’s too sensitive about how people think of
him; he doesn’t want Nick to think him as too pushy. Both my ideas doesn’t
correlate with ‘tough’, so….what does that mean, can anyone help me?
~~~~~~
eh, itu ilustrasinya keren, mbk :D #salahfokus
ReplyDeleteNah kan...itu dia gunanya majang image keren, kena deh korban pertama! :P
DeleteYou can't repeat the past...huhuhu kena banget deh aku sama kalimat ini, sampe terngiang2 setelah baca bukunya. Emang bener ya, harapan itu lebih indah dari kenyataan - karena harapan lah yang bikin kita bertahan.
ReplyDeletebtw..tentang yang a regular tough... aku juga nggak ngerti deh.. kalo google2 sih sepertinya bener, maksudnya bahwa gatsby is a violent person... tapi kok seperti kurang nyambung dengan makna kalimat keseluruhannya ya?? mentok nih.
Nah, jadi sebenarnya seringkali kita tetap membutuhkan harapan itu kan? Makanya aku gak bisa sepenuhnya menyalahkan Gatsby, walau cara2 dia mewujudkan harapan itu agak2 menyerempet kriminal. Tapi bisnis yang sangat berhasil pastilah ada unsur2 itu juga meski sedikit, there's no purity in business, eh?.
DeleteYg regular tough aku tetap bingung, kalau menurut aku di situ Gatsby sebenarnya terlalu khawatir kalau Nick tersinggung sehingga rencananya gagal. Kalau itu sih persistence 'kali ya? Apakah tough = persistent? Mmmm....nyerempet2 lah :))
I felt the same about Daisy and Gatsby's meeting. I think Gatsby had created a perfect picture in his mind of Daisy and nothing could live up to that reality. I think Jordan's comment about Gatsby being "regular tough" actually means the opposite, that's he's really sensitive underneath it and is worried his plans will offend Nick. It's a strange way to say it, but that was my interpretation.
ReplyDeleteThanks for enlightening me. Now I think maybe 'regular tough' isn't tough at all, anyway.
Deleteyour favorite passages, the second one, was no ordinary for me too.
ReplyDeletethe last line of the second passage caught me for seconds :)
You mean: "No amount of fire or freshness can challenge what a man can store up in his ghostly heart." ? Yeah....it lead us to a deeper reflection.
DeleteAh! Now I see. I had that one line about the green light quote in chapter 4 in my summary yesterday, but I took it out because I was stuck on what to say about it. But now it is clear: once Gatsby reunited with Daisy, it wasn't such a challenge anymore. The chase is always more exciting.
ReplyDeleteYep, moreover, Gatsby found that the present Daisy is not the one he'd been obsessed with for five years.
Delete