Agnes Grey is Anne Brontë's first novel
- an autobiographical account of her views and experience as a governess.
Although not as poignant and complicated as her second work - her magnum opus -
The Tenant of Wildfell Hall;
still, Agnes Grey is way deeper than Jane Eyre or Wuthering Heights (sorry #TeamCharlotte and #TeamEmily!) -
though perhaps less poignant.
Agnes is the youngest daughter of a clergyman with humble means. The story of
how Mrs. Grey, despite of coming from a rich family, deliberately sacrificing
her privilege, to live in a small parsonage with a humble husband, is very
inspiring. Indeed, a woman of high morality and strong character is always a
good mother. When Mr. Grey's financial investment failed, instead of moaning
their misfortune and accusing the father, all the Grey women rolled their
sleeves, and each found something to earn money. Agnes became a governess for a
rich family: The Bloomsfield. Thus, in her 19 years of age, inexperienced, with
all her life socially shut off in a rural village, Agnes left home for the
first time in her life, to attend to her first job.
What a family, the Bloomfields is! Their rude, harsh, and shallow characters;
with such a bully pack of children, is more than enough to dispel any
respectable governess, even the experienced one. But Agnes, shy and meek she
seemed to be, heroically bore all assaults while keep doing her best to impart
goodness to her pupils. It's so ridiculous how Mrs. Bloomfield expected the
governess to educate her children WITHOUT giving her any authority. This
account was actually derived from Anne's own experience as a governess. That
people like this ever existed! (-_-') It's remarkable how Agnes endured all
that until she was finally dismissed (not of her fault) by the Bloomfields. But
the dismissal is really Godsend, since those people are hopelessly incurable!
Agnes' second job with the Murrays is much better - at least they treated her
more humanly. Even Rosalie Murray treated Agnes quite good - at least, in her
selfish way. Then the story gets far more interesting when Mr. Weston, the
young new curate, appeared on the radar, and... well, you know what is going to
happen next.
On the whole, this is another quiet bildungsroman story about strong women; a
soothing read, not too much conflict, and a perfect book for young women. It
teaches us how family education is the most important foundation to shape our
children's character; and that that education should be started from very early
age, when they are still malleable. It also criticizes how 19th century society
treated woman as man's slave in marriage. For 19th century woman, Anne Brontë
was way more forward than her peers. It's a good proof of a great mother will
likely produce great offspring.
Rating: 4 to 5
I enjoyed this book. Anne is such an honest writer about life. Agnes sure had some harrowing experiences as a governess!
ReplyDeleteHonest and so talented! :)
DeleteI read this years ago and really liked it, though it was depressing how Agnes (and presumably the Bronte sisters themselves) was treated as a governess. In some ways times haven't changed... I think people still expect teachers to be superheroes without any authority over the students! :P
ReplyDeleteIndeed, the way some people treat their household assistant is quite terrifying. They often forget that they (the assistants) aren't robot!
DeleteUh oh! I think of myself as #TeamCharlotte, but I haven't read any Anne so I've been meaning to check this out (& Wildfell Hall as well). This does make it sound like I've been missing out.
ReplyDeleteHa! After reading Wildfell Hall, you would regard Anne in completely different view, Reese! :)
DeleteOut of Anne's 2 books, I prefer Tenant, but Agnes Grey is still a nice story.
ReplyDeleteSame here. Tenant has become one of my most favorite.
Delete