First of all, Penguin Classics should
put a subtitle “and other writings” after Metamorphosis
for this edition. I have a habit of ignoring list of contents or notes, because
chapters/part titles often reveal the story plot. For me, curiosity is part of
reading excitement, thus I don’t like anyone to reveal anything before I read
it myself. When I need a reference or anything to help me understanding a
passage, I will consult the introduction or list of contents myself.
So, without any subtitle, I assumed
that when I opened the first page of the story, it had to be The Metamorphosis. “The Contemplation”—printed largely on first page—I
assumed to be a part title (silly me! -_-). And so I read on, chapter after
chapter, yet I could not find any thread. Every chapter seemed to be
independent story, though it also felt incomplete. Until I finally reached the
part of The Metamorphosis. Only then
I knew there’s something wrong. I consulted the “note on the text” in the front
pages, and found that “The stories in
this collection were written…..” Oh OK! It’s a story/journal collection
then, not a single novella!
The first collection was Contemplation, written in first person
POV. All of them have one same tone: wary, dejected, and lonely. The Metamorphosis itself had the same
tone. The protagonist (Gregor) feels alienated and burdened by his job. But
what disturbed me most is the reaction of his father, mother, and most of all,
his sister, against his metamorphosis. The disgust is one thing, but how can
they not feel any affection about their son/brother, that they want to get rid
of him? It was Gregor who has provided for them before the metamorphosis, how
easy it is for them to ignore his sacrifices!
In the next stories/journals, lack of
recognition theme came again. In fact, I have jotted down aspects or themes
that are interesting and quite often appeared throughout the book, here they
are:
Engineer
Businessman
Lack of recognition
from authority
“Life is
astonishingly brief”
Huge gap
between superior and inferior
Lack of
gratitude > slaving
Mechanical
structure
Wary
Dejected
Lonely
Suicidal
behavior
No way out
Metamorphosed
to animal
Caged >
helplessness
So I think, to better understanding
Kafka, or the meaning of his writings, is to find the connecting thread.
Unfortunately I am quite hectic at present to much analysis, but I think it’s
safe to conclude that Kafka wrote this book out of disappointment of his own
life and maybe, of the social condition. To what and why? I have still much to analyze… or do you know? Have you
read the book? What is your conclusion?
That's too bad about this edition. I'm exactly the same way - I avoid *anything* that could give spoilers. And with Kafka, whose narrative is already rambling, I can see how it would be confusing!
ReplyDeleteYou pretty much hit upon the main themes of The Metamorphosis. From what I've heard, a number of his writings are veiled commentaries on his difficult relationship with his own father.
Personally I love The Metamorphosis because to me it's about a person with a disability (physical or mental) and how society's view of them changes when they go from "working" member to "dependent" member. It's really sad, but it seems to actually depict how a lot of elderly people are treated. Kafka's story, of course, is more dramatic because it's about a young man.
Hi MH, apology for my late reply...
DeleteI have guessed that Kafka somehow had difficult relationship with his father, which then inspired his writings. So, it's true, then...
It's interesting what you said about treatment of elderly people, I haven't thought that.
Wow...that title thing would have annoyed me. I'm with you on reading curiosity, so I also avoid looking at chapter names, forwards, and the like.
ReplyDelete