In a crime story,
Perry Smith would definitely be the antagonist, because he is the murderer.
However, In Cold Blood is not merely
a crime story; it is a warning for us that the whole society is responsible to build
either good or bad people. Murderers or criminals are not born as criminals at
first; they are all born as innocent babies; they start life as we all do: as a
blank sheet of paper, ready to be filled with scripts of life. Here in this story, Perry Smith is not only a
villain, he is also a victim.
The series of
failure in the development of little Perry has begun—at least—from his parents.
After his father decided to have contraband alcohol business for living, Perry’s
mother began to get drunk, and other bad things started to follow. They
quarreled often, and I guess peace and love have slowly evaporated from their
home and family, replaced by violence. Perry was a child with sensitive and
tender heart who should be taken in special care; he needed love, affection and
tenderness much more than anybody else with different personalities. These violent
episodes in the family, unfortunately, happened on the very important phase of Perry’s
early development.
After that, his
parents separated, and Perry must enter several institutions, and there he did
not get any better treatment either. And that because people failed to
understand Perry’s needs. If only they gave him love, acceptance and support, I
believe it is not too late to bring him to the right path. But, it never
happened, and with all the violence he got, he got worse. As a result, Perry
grew up as a man with hatred and grudge deep inside him. In the surface he
might be a feminine man who loved poetry and cared about others (he really
provided comfort for his victims-to-be before he killed them), but inside, he
still bore the needs to inflict upon people who had treated him cruelly and
unfairly, people who had humiliated him.
The interesting
aspect here, is how Perry put the blame not on several certain people who had
really troubled him, but on the whole world. It was between he, Perry, and the
world. At the end, the instinct of killing occupied him. It didn’t matter who
the victim would be, the only matter was that Perry needed to let the world
know what they had done to him.
That is my Character Thursday of this week, an analysis of
book character of my choice, who is yours?... Just put your post URL in the linky
below. Do you like to join us in discussing characters from books you read? See
the details of Character Thursday first.
Wonderful assessment! Perry Smith is a very tragic person and despite the henious deeds he commits later in life felt sympathy for him. It sounds completely sick for me to say that, but as he will be immortalized in Truman Capote's In Cold Blood, I think it is very difficult to see past that to the life he led before November 1959.
ReplyDeleteYes, my symphaty is much deeper for Perry than his victims.
DeleteI completely agree after reading "In Cold Blood". I feel very sorry for the Clutters but I feel the same for Perry Smith and Richard Hickock.
ReplyDeleteYeah....they are victimes too (Perry and Richard), victims of the bad systems.
Delete